Kenya’s Supreme Court criticises IEBC electoral commission

Kenya’s Supreme Court criticises IEBC electoral commission

  • 20 September 2017
  • From the section Africa


Image caption

The judges ruled by a 4-2 majority to annul the 8 August election

Kenya’s Supreme Court has blamed the country’s electoral commission (IEBC) for its decision to annul the re-election of President Uhuru Kenyatta.

The judges said the 8 August poll was “neither transparent or verifiable”.

Deputy Chief Justice Philomena Mwilu said the IEBC did not verify the presidential results before they were announced.

Mr Kenyatta got 54% of the vote against opposition leader Raila Odinga’s 44%, according to the IEBC’s results.

Mr Odinga went to court alleging that he had been cheated of victory and that the IEBC had not followed the law in the conduct of the election.

The Supreme Court took the unprecedented step of annulling the election on 1 September but it has only now explained why it took that decision.

It was the first time in Africa that a court had agreed with an opposition demand to cancel a presidential election over rigging allegations.

Was the election hacked?

Ms Mwilu said that the commission had not complied with a court order to allow its electronic voting system to be scrutinised.

She said that the IEBC’s refusal to comply with the order to grant access to its electronic voting system led the court to “accept claims by the opposition that the computer system had been infiltrated and compromised and the data interfered with, or that the IEBC officials interfered with the system themselves”.

The electoral commission has disputed that its system was tampered with.

Meanwhile, outside the Supreme Court compound, police fired tear gas to disperse opposition supporters who had gathered to support Mr Odinga.

At one point a swarm of bees attacked some of them, injuring one man who is reported to have a physical disability.

Image copyright

Image caption

Opposition supporters allege that the IEBC tampered with its server to fix Mr Kenyatta’s win

Image copyright

Image caption

Police fired tear gas to disperse Mr Odinga supporters

Opposition coalition Nasa has been pushing for the sacking of IEBC officials whom it blames for bungling the polls, saying that a new team should be in charge of the re-run scheduled for 17 October.

Doubts have however been cast on this date because OT-Morpho, the French company that provided the voting kits, has said that it needs to reconfigure the more than 40,000 kits and that the process would not be complete until at least the end of October.

The judges had ordered the re-run to be held in 60 days.

Four judges voted to annul the election while two dissented. Another judge was taken ill during the hearing of the petition and did not take part in the case.

Key points from the judgement:

  • IEBC could not explain why the results from more than 11,000 polling stations had not been received at tallying stations as required by law
  • IEBC relied on interim reports by election observers to argue their case that the elections were credible
  • The opposition did not prove that the presidential campaign used public funds to pay for their electoral campaign
  • The Chief Justice said that the irregularities by IEBC would be found unconstitutional by any court “with its right mind”
  • Some ballot forms did not have security features